Claiming Victory in Jita!

We’ll beat the bailiffs out of fun,
We’ll make the mayor and sheriffs run
We are the boys no man dares dun
If he regards a whole skin.

-Verse from the Garryowen, a traditional Irish air

The “Burn Jita” event is officially over.

The thing about an event like “Burn Jita” is that it lacks any real, concrete goals.

Nobody, aside from the devs at CCP, can actually “burn” Jita.  Likewise, there is nothing any player can do to “save” Jita either.  Jita is a static element of virtual universe.  Players in the game have no ability to affect the virtual manifestation of the location in EVE Online known as Jita.  You cannot actually burn Jita.

So for the event, you can pretty much craft your own victory conditions.

Certainly The Mittani, back from his ban, is claiming total victory.  But his victory is a macro-economic victory bound up with the control of the technetium needed to replace all the ships blown up in Jita and the subsequent Hulkageddon event, leading to economic dominance.  To mis-quote Mao, power comes from the barrel of a Goon.

Others, such as the EVE Morning podcast seem dubious, though they seem to be focused on one aspect of the plan and only in the short term.  They are claiming victory for the opposition, I suppose.

Then there is the gank fleet.  The certainly blew up some freighters.  In the 12 months previous to the event, 23 freighters and 3 jump freighters had been destroyed in Jita.  The event took down 38 freighters and 9 jump freighters.  More than a year’s worth of carnage in just three days, plus a few more in the surrounding systems as well.  Jester has a “Butcher’s Bill” and some analysis on the big kills.

Freighters Destroyed

The Save Jita folks are certainly claiming victory.  They flew in Jita and sought out the gank fleet.  Having declared war on Goonswarm and other alliances, they were free to engage in combat.  And they definitely blew up their share of gank ships.

But the presence of the “Save Jita” forces, clear for CONCORD free combat, brought an additional group of players into the mix in the form of the gank defense fleets.  CFC players who had no real interest in suicide ganking got to come out to Jita and engage in fleet PvP fights.  And so they got to show up, PVP, kill stuff, and have a good time.  Another victory!

All of this adds up.  You can go to DOTLAN and see that jumps in and out of Jita seemed close to the normal pattern. (Though Burn Jita even hit DOTLAN hard, causing some data loss.)  Jita interdiction fail!  But the total number of ship and pod kills in the system, which usually sits between 2,500 and 4,000 on any given month, spiked to almost 13,000.  And that number was heavily weighted towards the last three days of the month.

Jita Jumps and Ship Kills in April

Then there are the other players, those in system neither to gank nor defend.  Some clearly “lost,” in that their ship was blown up.  But every hauler who entered the war zone, loaded or unloaded, and made the run back out, can claim a victory of sorts.  They lived while others perished.

And for those of us who were just there as spectators, it was a chance to see and be, if only in a small way, a part of one of those great EVE Online events.  Burn Jita will be one of those things mentioned for years afterwards, and we were there to see it and to suck up system resources.  We helped lock down Jita at times by sending it to the limit of its capacity.  I claim victory for myself.  And I have some video to prove it. (The most popular “Burn Jita” video in all of Poland!)

And finally, there is CCP.  They got a clear victory with the press coverage.  And, in an interview with EuroGamer, they got to make their stance on the whole event quite clear.

“Do you want to play a 15 minute match of Call of Duty that you won’t remember the next day, or do you want to spend four months manufacturing 14,000 Thrashers to do this? It’s just so big and awesome.”

“We want people to be able to do this. If Goonswarm want to do it, we want them to do it and we want them to have a great time doing it.

“The worst thing we could do is to stop it happening. It would be appalling for the game. It would be against everything we stand for.”

Not a lot of ambiguity in that.  CCP digs this sort of thing.

So there are many out there who can claim a victory.  That, in itself, is probably a pretty good sign that the event was a success.

Of course, one sign of victory is the desire to do it again.  And I think that will happen.

The musical question might just be, “How are you going to keep them down on the farm after they’ve burned Jita?”

What do you think?  Who can claim victory in Jita?

And what will you do when it comes time for Jita (or maybe Amarr) to burn again?

14 thoughts on “Claiming Victory in Jita!

  1. Luk

    Thanks for an objective analysis of the Jita thing. Nice read since you are not spinning it in Goons favour (for once). Also love the Mittens picture at the beginning.

    Like

  2. Wilhelm Arcturus Post author

    “Nice read since you are not spinning it in Goons favour (for once).”

    For once? Please point at a post where I was “spinning” something (by which I am going to guess you mean “lying”) in favor of the Goons as opposed to reporting what I heard and saw.

    Like

  3. NoAstronomer

    Who won? I think the game did. If they turn up to burn Amarr maybe I’ll be there to pick up some scraps.

    Like

  4. Luk

    Maybe “spinning” is not a correct word, but it is quite obvious that your blog is Goon biased. Goon’s propoganda notwithstanding, your blog is fun to read, so I apologize for implying that you were lying.

    On a different note, please do not add me to the Goon hit list, pretty please.

    Like

  5. Lewis Maskell

    I think Wilhelm since you moved out into null your blog has taken on a tone perhaps more favourable to Goonswarm than it previously did – which is pretty much as expected since you are flying along side those folks. I mean, no one can really avoid being biased. Your blog is informed by your experiences – and would be worthless to read if it was not. But that does mean right now you are in The Mittani’s/Goonswarms “camp” as it were.

    As to the next event – pretty much what I did this one (and I do for all the Hulkageddons) – mostly just ignore it, other than perhaps wonder yet again at the silliness of some EVE players.

    The thing is, I am sure Goonswarm (and others) could, if dedicated enough, cause enough disruption to shift trade in hisec – but The Mittani is wise to have this as a time-limited thing. To properly Burn Jita would require alot more persistence and sec-status grinding than the vast majority of people would want to do.

    All this said, I think your post about how various groups of people can claim victory is a good one – but going back to the bias – starting and ending with The Mittani does reinforce the idea you are currently rooting for Goons/The Mittani – regardless of whether or not you actually are :).

    Like

  6. Wilhelm Arcturus Post author

    @Luk – Well, yes, I clearly write form that point of view, as my alliance, TNT, is allied with the Goons. (And about 98% of the people I have run into in the CFC have been very nice, Goons included.)

    I do try to make an effort to not over-play things when my own side is winning, if only because victory is often boring, while failure and defeat are interesting.

    I am not sure I have enough juice to get anybody on The Mittani’s enemies list yet. I posted to the Goon forums for the first time the other day and achieved negative reputation immediately because I linked things in the wrong fashion and signed my post. (Though that changed when somebody noticed it was my first post and pointed out the error of my ways. So I am back to neutral again.)

    Like

  7. Wilhelm Arcturus Post author

    And clearly I have not covered all of the stakeholders in this event. One comment from my video (since removed by the author):

    “Hopefully this will show that concord needs to be upgraded O_o”

    Like

  8. Toldain

    “power comes from the barrel of a Goon”

    Ohhh, no. You didn’t? You did. Could you hear me groan here in Mountain View?

    Like

  9. Wilhelm Arcturus Post author

    BTW, I totally stole the idea for the “Y U NO” guy from somebody in a comment thread at EVE News 24, but I forgot who. So, if you see this, “Hey thanks!”

    Like

  10. Default

    Well, I claim victory for myself. I blew up 8 Goon pods in Jita (between 4 characters) after the gank attempts :)

    Like

  11. Pingback: EVE Online MMO Universe Analysis Using Social Network Analysis | Joe Shaheen the HR Machine

Voice your opinion... but be nice about it...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s