The 365 Day LOTRO Anniversary Contest is over, the entries have been reviewed and ranked, and a winner must be declared!
The Rating System
With only four entries in the contest, two of which showed up with less than 24 hours to go, the review process was not very difficult.
I put all of the entries up on my screen in PaintShop Pro, asked my wife to come rate them, and had the results. Her rankings matched mine, if not always for the exact same reasons, so that was that.
The third place entry came from Ilya, who was also the person who provided the subject for last week’s reader mail question. His entry did not thrill my wife. She described it as a “troll walking towards a pool of blood.” I did not point out that it was in fact a Hobbit as her views on trolls tend to be more influenced by “The Three Billy Goats Gruff” rather than the high fantasy milieu. But I got her point, the picture was quite clearly from LOTRO, but a bit grim looking, and so it came in third place.
Second place went to Gaff who sent in, at my prompting, this picture in front of the boar fountain in Bree. (The fountain is, no doubt, a memorial to all the boars that gave their lives helping level up so many adventurers.) My wife liked this picture quite a bit as it gave a very tangible view of a place in Middle-earth.
First place went to Justin for his misty golden landscape banner. My wife was drawn to it immediately, saying it made her feel like adventure and discoveries were almost within sight. This from somebody who really is not into the genre. I had to agree that it was a beautiful shot, and so it is up as the banner on the site today. The only problem with it is that the white lettering for the site name gets somewhat washed out
Since I will, eventually, have nine 30 day LOTRO time codes to give away, and since there were only three entries, I have decided to send a time code to each of the three participants.
The time codes should be in your email inbox by the end of the day.
Thank you to those who took the time to enter the contest!
The Other Entry
I said there were four entries at the top. The other entry came from a co-worker who does not play LOTRO and who seemed determined to break as many of the contest rules as he could. So he:
- Did not size it correctly
- Attached it as a .bmp
- Sent it to the wrong email address
- Used artwork from Turbine
- Threw it together in MS Paint
This is what he sent:
I need an idea for another LOTRO contest. Feel free to leave a comment or drop me an email if you have a suggestion.