Being Evil in LOTRO Chat

I must admit that it is nice to be playing Lord of the Rings Online.

The word “nice” applies to so many aspects of the game.  The scenery, the effects, the classes, the skills (both trade and combat), the zones, the quests, and the other players are, generally, nice.  That is the word that keeps coming to mind for me.  Not great, gigantic, or outstanding, just nice.

Not that you should take that as a slam on the game in anyway.  It seems to strive to be nice.  It is the well behaved child in the family that doesn’t use bad words, that does what its told, that is polite, and does not get involved in anything unseemly like RMT, or even PvP except in the most round about way. (Okay, go dress up as a monster, then I’ll walk in the room and you jump out and scare me!)

So sure, it isn’t as dynamic, colorful, or fun at parties as some other games, but maybe you’ve grown up some and you want a stable relationship with nice.

I think there is a market for nice.

Even the chat channels are nice.

Over the course of a week I played EVE Online, EverQuest II, World of Warcraft, and Lord of the Rings Online, and LOTRO was certainly the easiest to deal with when it came to random stranger chat.  It was nice.  It was certainly so compared to WoW where logged on one of my alts on which, for the Lord only knows what reason, I had not yet turned off every single public channel, and it was like a scene where you press a button on somebody’s entertainment system only to have bad heavy metal music blare out at 11 while you try to figure out how to shut it off… only in chat text laced with internet acronyms and WoW slang.

Having all channels on in LOTRO, on the other hand, is a pleasant little stream of questions and people looking for fellowships (groups) for a quest that is easy to follow in a single window.  Sure, once in a while somebody seems to think that you must broadcast your request on the looking for fellowship channel every 15 seconds or somebody might miss it, but I have yet to find a game where that sort of over aggressive repetition doesn’t happen once in a while.  And they are always nice about it.  It is never in, say, all caps or anything.

Granted, people can get their noses a little bent out of shape in protecting this niceness when somebody dares to use the trade channel to actively, you know, sell stuff.  But otherwise it is mostly a very pleasant give and take.

LOTRO chat can be so nice that every so often people begin chatting about how nice it is.  I’ve run into this a few times.

Such a conversation was going on Sunday evening on OOC.  Several people were going on about how nice people were in LOTRO, and how polite, and how mature, and how unlike WoW it was, and on and on.  They began to speculate on why that was, doing into the depth and scope of the subject matter and how wonderfully rich and deep the books on which the game was based were.

At which point I just had to type into OOC, “STFU Noob! It wasn’t based on books! It was based on movies! WTF?!1

Then I began to count slowly in my head.

The channel remained silent until I hit 20, when I then typed, “Sorry, just had to remind you of what you were missing.

That got a “Heh” or two in response, but I was probably on a few ignore lists by that point.  And it killed the discussion, which was fine.  It was drifting a bit too close to the shores of sanctimony in any case.

I mean, nice is fine and all, but let’s not go overboard patting ourselves on the back about it.

Maybe I’m not as nice as I thought.

23 thoughts on “Being Evil in LOTRO Chat

  1. Wilhelm2451 Post author

    In hindsight, my statement was probably far too well spelled and composed to be taken for the real thing… and, of course, there is the caps issue.


  2. Khan



    I’ve noticed it really depends on where I am as to the quality (or lack thereof) of the chat. The Shire seems pretty civil most of the time. Breeland, not so much. I’m still in the habit of turning off all the chat channels when I start a new char though.


  3. Scott

    Probably depends on the server. Brandywine is the most populated server and can sometimes be the most WoW-like (well, as much as LOTRO players get WoW-ish anyway).

    Also check to see what global user channels your server has. Most servers have a GLFF that is very popular, since the normal LFF (and OOC) channels are zone-specific, it’s easy to miss an LFF for something you want to do if you’re in a different zone. Some have a GOOC too although on Arkenstone we tend to use GLFF for OOC-ish conversation. The Chat Police occasionally rear their heads but we’re usually good about policing ourselves and it’s a user channel anyway not an “official” channel.

    Oh, and you were probably just saying that for dramatic effect, but the game is in fact based on the books not the movies… :) EA has the movie game rights.


  4. mbp

    I used to think that it was an age thing. Lotro players seem to be a bit older than the average WOW player. Now I wonder if game design doesn’t come into it. The fact is (and I am a fan) that Lotro has plenty boring bits among the loveliness. It doesn’t offer much in the way of ph4t l3wt as a carrot for dealing with those boring bits and the game as a whole is extremely un-competitive.

    I think that all the competitive, irritable folks with low boredom thresholds left LOTRO early on leaving behind the “nice” people who are playing the game today.

    You can take this however you want. Perhaps the “nice” people who still play the game are just boring losers or perhaps they are just, well, nice.


  5. arbitrary

    yeah, the ‘nice’ community and chat channels mean I’ve never switched off a channel in LotRO, though sometimes I get a bit tired by debating RP things (I am on a RP server, so these things come up from time to time).

    I’m finding it really really strange to have so many bloggers discussing LotRO!


  6. dmosbon

    Like the old saying goes, we get the rulers we deserve but in this case an MMO gets the players it deserves.


  7. Pingback: Don’t Fear the Mutant » Blog Archive » Back in the Ring

  8. Salindor

    heh im on firefoot and no one there ever works on vol1 is it the same way in all the other servers or do people actually take the time to do it. because if theres a server where alot of people actually do vol1 i might actually switch servers


  9. Ymarsakar

    Most people don’t want to lead groups. So they may want to do an instance or epic, but they’re waiting… for a leader.


  10. Ebbi

    I play on gilrain and yup its very “nice” haha. But as an ex wow player I must admit it makes a nice change, but i have great memorys of just typing “look at my horse” and the rest of the server took over and sang it.. that was pretty amazing.. i doubt lotro people would know what it is? xD

    But i love lotro <3


Voice your opinion... but be nice about it...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s