Down on the Farm

In which we discuss FarmVille.

Shut Up, We’re Talking episode #60 was recorded this past weekend and I was invited to be a guest on the show.  One of the topics of the show was Facebook games.

While the show is being prepared for release, I thought I might give some background about our prep for the show as well as my own impressions of the game FarmVille.

Your first question might be, “Why FarmVille?”

Certainly there are many other games on Facebook.  But FarmVille is the poster child for these games.  It is Zynga‘s biggest success, with an award at GDC and 82 million players.

Yes, you read that right, 82 million players.

From the information tag that Facebook puts up about the game:

I don’t know exactly how they calculate that number, but it sure is a big one.  That would be about 1.2% of the world’s population.  As a country, FarmVille would push Germany out of 14th place on the list of most populous countries and it would be eyeballing Vietnam.

This is the World of Warcraft of Facebook games.  And, as you couldn’t get very far talking about subscription MMORPGs without mentioning WoW, so it was felt that if we we’re going to talk about these casual, social network site based games, we would have to put in some time down on the farm.

Darren got a bit of a head start on the FarmVille fun and posted about his initial impressions already.

My own impression of the game after a week or so can be summed up as, “Eh, it’s not so bad.”

FarmVille is the classic simulation game where you start with a limited set of resources, money in this case, which you can use to buy seeds to plant which, when they mature, you can sell for more cash than you spent.  Thus enriched, you can turn around and buy more seeds, or trees, or livestock, which you then harvest in turn.

The environment is very simple.  The price you get for your crops is fixed.  You know up front how much money you are going to get when you plant.  You also know how much time the crop will take to mature (anywhere from a couple of hours to four days) so you can easily calculate the optimum crop for your needs.

There are two currencies, Farm Coins, which you get for most activities, and Farm Cash, which you only get for special events… so special in fact that I haven’t quite figured that out yet.  Oooh, complexity.

Currency is one aspect of the game, and if you run short, Zynga will glad sell you some to speed things up.

Exchange Rates Are Available For Most Major Currencies

There is also a leveling aspect to the game.  Certain actions, like tilling the soil to prepare it for planting, or harvesting some crops, earn you experience.  Experience gets you levels.  Levels open up new crops to plant and equipment for use on the farm.

You also earn experience for helping out your neighbors.

While I reject these games being called “social games,” if only because of the implication that the games I play, and have played for more than 20 years, are some how not social, there is something of a social aspect to them.

Certain things you can only accomplish via your friends and neighbors.  For example, there seems to be only two ways to expand the size of your farm.  The first route is with Farm Cash.  That is in short supply, probably to encourage you to buy some, thus fund the game.

Or you can buy the expansion with Farm Coins, which are plentiful, but only if you have met a minimum threshold for neighbors.

So to expand my farm up to the Homestead size, I need 20 Farm Cash (I have only acquired 15 so far) or 8 neighbors.  I only have three neighbors so far, Darren, Karen, and a woman name Mandi whom I don’t know, but who is a level 33 farmista (and shriner) and is, if you want to play this game, the neighbor and friend you desire.

Your friends and neighbors are the key to success in the game.  And all those annoying posts on your wall from your FarmVille playing friends, those are mana for people actually playing the game.

What is an annoyance to you is a free gift, an upgrade for the farm, to a player.

There is, in fact, almost a cult of the free gifts.

You are encouraged, if you idle in the game, to send gifts to your friends and neighbors.  These are often things that are useful, like fruit trees or livestock.  When you receive a gift you are encouraged to send a thank you gift in return.

And thus is the circle of gifts reinforced.

At first I felt silly with the constant gift giving.  FarmVille = annoying has been drummed into my head for a while now, so deliberately sending things from the game to people seemed like a bad idea.  But when you are playing the game, theses messages and gifts are good things.

Unfortunately, that is about it for the social.  You can send gifts to each other, read about each other on your wall, and even make a solo visit to each others farms.  You cannot, however, actually play the game together.  The closest you can come is leaving behind little messages when you visit.

So was it fun?

A bit.  It would be on the Taipan! level of fun for me I’d say.  A lot slower, but a lot more cute I guess.

You don’t have to invest a lot of time in the game.  You can come and go with the timing of your crops, with a stop in to fertilize the farms of your neighbors.  And it has a minor SimCity-like note to it, building and creating, that has some appeal to me.

And while we were, in part, playing the game for the lulz, once we all grouped around as neighbors, things picked up.  We spread the gifts around, did chores on the farms of the others, and left the occasional goofy message.  Even Darren picked up and ran with it after I came from behind and passed him in levels.  Nothing like a little healthy social competition I suppose.

But it was frankly much more fun to sit around before and during the show and talk about our experiences than it was to actually play the game.  In other words, it was more fun to be social than to play a so-called “social game.”

FarmVille wasn’t the only game we played.

Among us we played Mafia Wars, Vampire Wars, My Tribe, YoVille, D&D Tiny Adventures, NanoStar Siege, Bejeweled Blitz, and a few others.   We speak about many of them on the show.  I’ll take some time to write about a few of them here, though not all of them.  For example, I feel about Mafia Wars and its reskinned clone, Vampire Wars, about the way Darren felt about FarmVille in his first impressions post.

Will I keep playing FarmVille?  Probably for a bit.  It is pretty light and I am fond of the SimCity-like genre of simulation games.  Plus I have to keep ahead of Darren.

If you want to give it a try, you can always send a friend invite to Wilhelm Arcturus and add him as a neighbor.

And, yes, that is a real picture of me on my profile.  It is from 1988, and I am feeding a baby kangaroo.  That is my biggest mustache ever.

9 thoughts on “Down on the Farm

  1. Facepalm

    That ‘stache is legit!

    I played FarmVille for about 3-4 months with friends/family. It definitely was good to start, but after awhile…and as your farm gets bigger, it just turns into a chore. Optimization features (bigger tractors, fuel, etc.) cost money…any ploy to get you paying. Anyways, I gave up on it…level 42 is all she wrote.


  2. ishtare

    There’s one thing that gets under my skin a little with these facebook games, and that’s the way the press seem to lump them in with MMO’s as if this is a new direction for MMO’s.

    What most people forget is that most of the farmville-ish games are not in any way MASSIVELY MULTI-PLAYER! sure a lot of people play them but the extent of your “multi-player” experience is harrassing friends to join up and give you gifts, which is about as multi-player as myself buying a friend a gift game on steam!

    It’s basically a lot of people playing a single player game using a 3rd party website to socialise in.

    Anyway *rant over*

    (oh and don’t even get me started on the fact I was playing these games 10 years ago! rehashing old games is not “forward thinking” its taking theme hospital, adding a cash cow cash shop and sticking it in a flash engine!)


  3. Pingback: In which my social game test doesn’t even last for one week « Welcome to Spinksville!

  4. JohnO

    It is shameful that I sent you friend request solely for the purpose of having more friends than my wife in Farmville?


  5. *vlad*

    I played Harvest Moon on the Gameboy. While that was typically wierd as some Japanese games can be, it was great fun.
    This sounds like a clone, so I would be interested if anyone else has played both.
    No sweeter feeling than throwing your vegetables into the big bin and waiting to collect your money!
    Even better when you can afford to get the Sprites to do all your donkey work for you, and you can spend time round at the girl next door’s farm!


  6. Wilhelm2451 Post author

    @Facepalm – That thing was a biker chick magnet too. The effects of facial hair on female attraction… a subject to be explored.

    @Ishtare – Oh, there is much to get under one’s skin about the way that these Facebook games are being hyped. We get into that quite a bit on the show, and the links to supporting articles will be bigger than normal.

    But for this I wanted to separate a game itself from the hype and misinformation that is going around.

    @JohnO – Neighbor me!

    @Vlad – When you get high enough level, and rich enough, you can hire farm hands it seems. Or at least ride around on a big harvester. So, sounds like a clone. Or a clone or a clone, from what I’ve read.


  7. Wilhelm2451 Post author

    Oh, and more trivia about that Facebook profile picture. On the front breast of that US Navy G-1 flight jacket (Korean war vintage) there is an ID patch with flight wings and the name “Wilhelm.” That was from the Air Warrior convention they held in Dayton, Ohio back in… I’m going to say 1988.

    And under it is a TimeCon ’88 T-shirt, a local SciFi convention that used to be held down by the airport, which featured on the front a picture of the face on Mars, back when our imaging resolution was so bad that it actually looked like a face.


  8. bluelinebasher

    I’m with JohnO — after being harassed by my wife to join, I am now set out to catch her. But the lack of FarmVille neighbors is holding me back. Is there a TAGN network of farmers? Neighbor me!


  9. Pingback: Journeys with Jaye » Facebook Games

Voice your opinion... but be nice about it...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s