And What of Middle-earth?

Here we are in 2014 and the news coming out of Turbine is… odd.

It was previously announced that there was to be no new expansion for LOTRO in 2014, a change up from their annual ritual of hawking extra pre-order goodies and special cosmetic gear for the Super Special Collector’s Edition of whatever bit of Middle-earth is being targeted.  While the effort behind an expansion no doubt eat up a lot staff hours, those are people on staff.  Turbine isn’t doing binge and purge staffing for projects that I have heard, so there are people on payroll to do the work.   So why not set them to churning out another beautiful cash cow depicting the fields of Pelennor or the Paths of the Dead or the Dead Marshes?  Drop in a few nifty cloaks, a special mount, and another experience boosting pocket item for those who buy in big, and Robert is thus reaffirmed as your mother’s brother or some such.  Basically, the same expansion plan we have every year.

Not that there are not some issues with business as usual.  There is the ever higher pile of levels and Turbine clinging onto the “you must buy every expansion” attitude that I think even EverQuest started to shed this many expansions in by offering “catch-up” bundles of all previous expansions.  Even Blizzard is doing that with their WoW Battlechest at this point (you could have had everything through Cataclysm for $5.00 over the holidays), while SOE went to a model of “the latest expansion gets you all previous expansions and the base game” back when they were a subscription only model, and moved to selling only the last two expansions and offering up everything else for free after the F2P conversion.

That whole thing is getting in the way of Turbine selling you an insta-leveled character, as they seem reluctant throw in an expansion or two with the deal, which leaves them stuck at boosting you to level 50 in a game already at level 95.  I suspect Turbine will see the light on this at some point, but it does call out how the baggage of so many expansions can restrict their options.

But there will be no expansion this year, so compounding the levels/expansions issue has been deferred.  So they must be working on something else then.  What could it be?

Pengail Attacks!

Making Pengail hate goblins eve more?

According to a recent LOTRO event, summed up at Contains Moderate Peril, no new dungeons or raids are planned.  Nor will housing see much attention nor kinships nor any such related items.  There was a mention of a potential revamp of one of the base game regions, though no region had been picked at this time.  There is still some tuning being done on the big skill and specialization revamp that came with the Helm’s Deep expansion.  But this event, taken with the producer’s letter from last month, certainly makes it feel as if Turbine doesn’t have much planned for LOTRO in 2014.

All of which makes me wonder if we are hitting a point of decision when it comes to the game.  As I noted way back in 2008, Turbine and Tolkien Enterprises signed a deal that gave Turbine rights to the property out through 2014.

And here we are in 2014.  How did that happen so fast?

So Turbine has been sitting on those rights for over seven years now.  But now we are at a renewal point.  Turbine has an option to extend to 2017, but the details around what rights Tolkien Enterprises might have at this juncture are unknown.  I suspect they have some ability to deny the extension, for a price, which would certainly leave Turbine in the lurch if that came to pass.  For money makers Turbine pretty much has LOTRO and Dungeons & Dragons Online, another licensed IP.  Meanwhile, Tolkien Enterprises, with part three of the movie series ostensibly based on the book The Hobbit coming out in December, might very well be wondering if their interests might be better served by selling whatever exclusive rights Turbine has been granted to some other studio.

Not that Tolkien Enterprises isn’t making money off of Turbine.  LOTRO has been successful enough when measured against a backdrop where EverQuest is the top dog, peaking at 550K subscriptions.  But few care about where EQ peaked in 2003 since World of Warcraft passed the 12 million subscriber mark post-Cataclysm.  Even the Turbine team is pretty blunt on that point when asked about subscriber numbers, with Sapience saying,

Unless we can say we have 10 million players and are bigger than WoW, what’s the point?

Life in the shadow.

So, do I think LOTRO is doomed to shut down this year?  It doesn’t seem highly likely.  Unless Tolkien Enterprises has another paying customer lined up and ready to go, LOTRO is still a revenue stream.  But I am going to guess that there are some negotiations going on as to the future of the license.  This in turn might mean some uncertainty for Turbine who, quite rightly, might not want to invest time and effort into a game whose future is in doubt.  Since the resources for projects are shared across teams, it might be better for them to bet on something with a more secure future.

But what will a quiet year of minor changes mean for LOTRO?  What will drive revenue if there is no expansion and few changes?

And do you think we will still be able to play the game in 2015?

Addendum: Contains Moderate Peril has a statement from Turbine about having an agreement that goes out until 2017.  “The license was renewed” was the phrase used, but some think there is some wiggle room in that, and it still doesn’t explain Turbine’s seeming mild interest in LOTRO for 2014.

8 thoughts on “And What of Middle-earth?

  1. Syl (@Gypsy_Syl)

    For LOTRO more than any other MMO, the prospect of it shutting down “halfway” through (as in any time soon) freaks me out. It’s the narrative aspect to ME – the fact that we all know how it’s supposed to go. and end. it’s bewildering to imagine Turbine having to pull the plug with the one ring still halfway to Moria. it’s all wrong.


  2. bhagpuss

    Reading those runes I’d be tempted to guess that Turbine either know or strongly suspect that this is their last year. I also thought it came across as very odd. To announce “No Expansion” could be considered no more than unexpected but to follow that up with “None of this either. Nor this. Nor yet that” goes past unexpected towards positively weird.

    Companies looking to make money out of an ongoing service usually like to tell you both how great it is and how much better still it’s going to be if you hang around. This doesn’t do that. At all.

    Even if it turns out that they do get the three year extension, with this plan they’ll have wasted a year of it marking time and will have lost a lot of momentum. If I was committed to LotRO I’d be feeling quite nervous right now.


  3. Telwyn

    I hope the game continues to its natural conclusion. Most MMOs lack a solid end-point story-wise, kind of like TV series they are kept alive way beyond their prime till they fade away. It would be good for the LOTRO story to be taken to Mordor with a big finish and then, like GW1, put in maintenance mode so people can continue to play the game for as long as there’s an audience.


  4. Wilhelm Arcturus Post author

    The funny thing is that I never really seriously considered the idea that we would ever get to the “end” such that it is. Having the whole story in an MMO, with various stages of the tale existing simultaneously, is such a strange thing for me at times that I am not sure it should get to its conclusion. Can we handle a world that has Frodo setting out on his journey AND casting the ring into Mount Doom occurring at essentially the same time, all the time?

    And then there is the whole real world timeline thing. In the books the whole tale is wrapped up in less than three years, and the war in two, with Helm’s Deep is about one year into it. Taking 7 years to get through the first year of the books means they had better have a plan to extend past 2017.


  5. bhagpuss

    Massively just reported that Turbine have confirmed they have the license to 2017. In my opinion that makes their recent announcements weirder still.

    What the heck are they up to?


  6. tsuhelm

    I think an old game such as LOTRO is in dire need of some housekeeping…and I hope TURBINE have realised the same…sure they have a large diehard hardcore of LOTR fanatics but to stay ‘alive’ they need to keep pulling in new players and wave MMO carrots at all the different flavours of MMO player. I think the HD expansion has already started this, I certainly think that there is more traffic in earlier areas in game…whether they are ‘newbies’ or ‘returnees’ trying to get to grips with the new skill tree by starting new chars…(really the trees are pretty basic…indeed I really HOPE they flesh them out this year!).
    Housing was supposed to have been given a lick of paint in 2013…they really need to have a good ‘home improvement’ session.
    The ‘large’ amount of bugs within the game can hopefully be exterminated!
    Hopefully on these new cleaned out foundations they can build a better and improved LOTRO.
    Consolidation is needed before any push forward and if they ever want to have that ring in that volcano they better be prepared.
    A BRAVE decision by TURBINE (I hope) I really hope it works :)


  7. Potshot

    Well if past is prologue, stopping the project before the “end” shouldn’t be an alien concept to the likes of Saul Zaentz. Roll file footage of the Ralph Bakshi/Zaentz film…


  8. Pingback: Turbine’s Future | Harbinger Zero

Voice your opinion... but be nice about it...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s