Google Plus Ungood Securewise

Alternate Headline: Users unbellyfeel Google prolefeed, becomes unservice.

It is probably just me that saw the Newspeak potential in the demise of Google Plus.

That attempt at humor aside, the word has gone out from the Googleplex in Mountain View that Google Plus will be no more.  Or that the consumer version of the product will be no more following a 10 month wind down, meaning that it will be gone at some point in August of 2019.  Google says that the enterprise version of Google Plus will continue.  Color me surprised that there was such a thing or that any enterprise outside of Google actually uses it, but they say “many” do.  I guess it is likely better than whatever Microsoft is pushing lately.  It is certainly better than anything Cisco has on offer.

The reason given for the closure in the news headlines involves a security flaw that could have potentially exposed the data for over half a million accounts.  The data exposed was limited to optional items entered in your Google profile (which is semi-public to start with unless you lock it down) and Google says it has no evidence that the flaw had been exploited.  But data breaches make for more views, so you may find your local news source pitching this as a stolen data panic.

The real reason for the closure is a little less dramatic.

Given these challenges and the very low usage of the consumer version of Google+, we decided to sunset the consumer version of Google+.

Basically, so few people use Google Plus that it isn’t worth the effort needed to keep it secure.  They didn’t just say “low” usage but “very low” usage.  You’ll probably get no greater admission of failure than that.  If it has been popular they would have kept it open.  But now they have an excuse to shut it down.

Of course, part of me cheered at the news.  I am old, have a long memory, and have been prone at times to carry resentments long past their expiration dates, so I continue to see Google Plus as the reason that Google killed off the much loved and still missed (by me at least) Google Reader.  It has been more than five years since that happened and I am still annoyed by it and I still haven’t found a replacement that did all Google Reader did at its peak.  Some twisted logic in the back of my brain sees this as justice for the late idolized RSS reader.

But a bit of me is bemused by the change.  As it turns out, I actually check Google Plus pretty much daily.  There are a few people I follow there, including Richard Bartle, that make it worth the effort. The updates aren’t rapid, so it is something I check once or twice a day at most, but I do check it.

I also syndicate my blog feed there as well and get the occasional response, so there is life out there still.  But the activity isn’t anywhere close to what it was during the early days of the service, which in itself wasn’t that much compared to the competition, which is and always was Facebook.  Nobody is saying Google Plus influenced the last election or anything else.

So I suppose I will miss it.  And I know that it going away won’t magically bring back Google Reader, so my missing it will be genuine.  You can’t blame a company for shutting down a service that few use and which brings in no revenue.  The same goes for Google Reader as well.  And iGoogle.  And Google Insights.  And Orkut.  Man, what is it with me and dead Google products?

And so it goes.  We’ll see how it winds down between now and August.

4 thoughts on “Google Plus Ungood Securewise

  1. anypo8

    Google is also shutting down its http:/ link shortener, which I liked to use because I trust Google to do a good job with it and keep the data private.

    The loss of Google Code Search a while back also hurts.

    While their rationale for closing these things is understandable, the bottom line for me is that I will be unlikely to adopt new Google services because I don’t trust them to sustain them for long (in real-world terms) periods. I tried out Google Classroom this Summer, and was thinking about using it again: I probably won’t now.

    By the way, I’m pretty happy with the free version of as a replacement for Google Reader. I forget now why I decided I had to leave now, but I really prefer this to that.

    We were never users of Orkut. We were always users of Google+.


  2. Wilhelm Arcturus Post author

    @anypo8 – Yes, jumping on board another Google science experiment at this point seems like a bad idea. Google is one of my prime examples of the Silicon Valley start-up problem where a company only has one successful product. Google does lots of things, but the search and ads group pays all the bills.

    I am pretty much locked into Feedly at this point as it is the base of my Rube Goldberg device to deliver the MMO Blog Feed to my side bar.


  3. bhagpuss

    I wonder how long Blogger has? It seems well-used for what it is but why would Google want to maintain it indefinitely. They do at least give good notice when they close things so I’m confident of having plenty of time to trasfer all the data to WordPress when the day comes. Whether WordPress will be able to handle the surge is another matter…


  4. Wilhelm Arcturus Post author

    @Bhagpuss – So Google is, as always, a strange bird. They aren’t closing Googe Plus down because it wasn’t making money. Literally nothing besides search and ads makes money for Google. Their metric for shutting something down mostly seems to be if few enough people are using it that it won’t cause a huge fuss. The only exception seems to be when they have a service that does the same thing, for various definitions of “same.” I am sure that somebody at Google saw Google Reader and Google Plus overlapping, so one had to go.

    Blogger still has enough people using it that I think it is safe for now. And, of course, the people who use blogger are self-identified as people who will complain on the internet.

    Things could get worse at Blogger though. It has been a long slumber or benign neglect for the most part. I think the last thing Google did was try to make you tie your Blogger login to Google Plus a few years back.

    But looking at how is evolving, I could see ads becoming more intrusive at Blogger is they ever suddenly decide it needs to produce more money.’s plan was originally to make money on a few people with deluxe packages and let everybody else ride for free, saying they might show ads. They they started showing ads on free sites once in a while. Then in more places. Then in even more places. Now if you go to Syp’s blog without Ad Block turned on, you’ll see ads in the in between posts, at the bottom of posts, and dropping down from the top of the page.


Voice your opinion... but be nice about it...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s