Streamers worried about getting their content pulled because they used music they didn’t pay for should be more worried by the fact that they’re streaming games they didn’t pay for as well. It’s all gone as soon as publishers decide to enforce it.
-Alex Hutchinson, Creative Director for something owned by Google, on Twitter
This was sort of toss out of left field I wasn’t expecting.
This all started on Wednesday when Amazon’s Twitch streaming service delete a large number of saved video stream for DCMA takedown requests without notice or an option to appeal, followed by an email about how streamers should familiarize themselves with the DCMA process… which isn’t supposed to work like that.
Twitch is Twitch
That is a whole tempest in itself, and Ars Technica has a good summary.
So a lot of streamers were pretty upset about this. And onto the hot coals of their ire, Mr. Hutchinson decided to pour is own oil of scorn.
This was followed by two more tweets:
Streamers worried about getting their content pulled because they used music they didn’t pay for should be more worried by the fact that they’re streaming games they didn’t pay for as well. It’s all gone as soon as publishers decide to enforce it.
The real truth is the streamers should be paying the developers and publishers of the games they stream. They should be buying a license like any real business and paying for the content they use.
Leaving aside the whole “kicking people when their down” aspect of this tweet, which is loathsome in itself, I can think of no quicker way to put an end to video game streaming that trying to extract a license tax from streamers. A few streamers make some decent money, but most make little to nothing, and any fee would just put a stop to them.
And he seems to be pretty sure that game publishers can make this happen. I’m not sure if the EULA and or ToS of every single video game is up to the task, but it is possible I suppose. Shut it all down. That is what he appears to want.
Remember, this comment is in a world where some game companies give popular streamers free copies of their games to play and often promote such streams.
And that isn’t the only problem with this sentiment. It also appears to equate video games with forms of entertainment like music or movies, things that yield the same experience if you buy it yourself or listen/watch somebody play it online. That seems to be a stretch for me. Watching people play video games is a very different experience in my book than actually playing a video game.
Then there is the fact that, here in 2020, that horse appears to be well and truly out of the barn and gone. If you can’t stream it, or have the saved recordings of those streams, what does that mean for YouTube? We’re about fifteen years down the road on game videos on that front.
However, I think the most shocking thing about these statements is that they don’t really seem to be something others in the industry have been grumbling about. “Streamers should be paying us!” isn’t something I’ve heard, and this is an industry that boils over now and then about used game sales, Steam sales, the cut apps stores (and Steam) take on sales, the cut physical retail stores take on sales, any barrier between them and publishing, too much competition due to lack of barriers to publishing, and the fact that people won’t spend their money on crappy 99 cent games rather than their morning latte.
Oh, and piracy. Always piracy. Literally a “make devs angry” thing for at least forty years, and one that has seen more money thrown at it for less benefit than anything I can think of.
But Mr. Hutchinson clearly sees this as piracy, so there is no doubt that fire in his belly on the topic, having been a game developer himself in the past. And, as was pointed out over at MMO Fallout, he has had his own issues in the past. and might even be stretching the truth in his Twitter bio.
The funniest thing about today’s streaming drama is that everyone thinks Alex Hutchinson runs Google Stadia (because his Twitter bio says “Creative Director @ Google Stadia”). He’s actually a creative director at a Montreal game studio that was purchased by Google last December
[He has since updated his profile to reflect this.]
Anyway, being a creative director of some sort at Google’s means he likely isn’t in a position to do anything about this. It looks like just so much hot air. And I doubt there are many studios out there keen to press this issue and make enemies of streamers. This is akin to the Mark Twain saying about not arguing with a man who buys ink by the barrel. The videos are already blossoming on YouTube and elsewhere about this. It may die down soon, but the embers will remain, ready to burst into flames it stoked.
I’m also pretty sure most game studios or publishers are smart enough give this idea a wide berth. Even EA can’t be dumb enough to get on board with this idea. And Google has made sure to carefully distance itself from the idea. In a statement they said:
The recent tweets by Alex Hutchinson, creative director at the Montreal Studio of Stadia Games and Entertainment, do not reflect those of Stadia, YouTube or Google.
Google is not keen to burn bridges or throw away whatever small success they have managed to eke out with Stadia.
So, in the end, one person’s noxious opinion did not represent their company or the industry and probably would have largely ignored if their profile had not represented their position as a senior exec at Stadia and not somebody in a subsidiary far from Google HQ. The status quo was maintained.
But, as we well know, the internet is a place where bad ideas find followers easily. This might come up again. Some other company exec, one with actual influence this time, could grab on tot his idea and run with it. And if they do, I’ll buy some popcorn. The drama will be excellent.
Others on this topic:
- MMO Fallout (different from the one I linked above)
- Techdirt
- Indiecator
- GamingSF
- GamesIndustry.biz
The Ancient Gaming Noob 