Gambling Returns to New Eden

I was sitting in bed this morning looking at Twitter on my iPad and saw that CCP had announced something called the HyperNet Relay.  I read through the post, but I was pretty sure I didn’t understand what it was or why anybody would want this, because it sure seemed like gambling, something CCP banned from the game in all forms back in 2016.

The New Face of Gambling in New Eden

Fortunately Twitter was there to help me out as not one but two CSM members responded to my sleep addled inquiries making clear that this was, in fact, a gambling scheme being introduced into EVE Online by CCP.

The CSM had clearly been briefed about the HyperNet Relay by CCP and had given it their approval, because a few of them were out fronting the feature for CCP on a variety of channels.

When explaining HyperNet Relay, the humble raffle seems to be the preferred metaphor.

That is a nice word, raffle, because it gets used by charities and other good causes which get an exception to gambling laws in some jurisdictions when using it as a mechanism for raising funds.  But make no mistake, a raffle is straight up gambling by any definition I have ever read.

So, gambling.  To say it is anything else is just a lie.

Basically, it sounds like CCP plans to let players set up their own raffles.  The player running the raffle basically buys the permit and the tickets from CCP through the New Eden Store with PLEX, the cash shop currency, and then lists their item.  Players then buy the tickets with ISK.  When all the tickets have been sold, RNG picks the winner.  Everybody else who bought a ticket is out the ISK they spent.

Checking in on the test server, where HyperNet Relay is now live, the tips for what it is show the usual level of CCP clarity…

How to gamble… I mean raffle… I mean HyperNet!

That gets you to the offers window, which has some sample raffles.

Welcome to wealth creation… not your wealth, but somebody’s

As far as bidding goes, the interface seems similar to a mob numbers racket, where you pick a ticket from an array.

Which one is the luck one?

On the creation side, once you get a HyperCore (this terminology has to be an attempt to stay as far away from gambling terms as possible) you drag an item into the interface and set the parameters of the raffle.

Time to generate wealth!

You can set the number of tickets in your raffle… erm, HyperNodes in your… raffle… which can be between 8 and 512, the price per ticket… node… whatever, or the total amount you want to make, which will set the per ticket price.

Looking at some of the raffles people have created, there is still some fuzziness on the idea.  I saw a Nyx listed with the per ticket price about the same as the price of a brand new, fully fit Nyx… only there were 48 tickets, so somebody wanted to sell for 48x the market price.

And, just looking at this, I can see how it will facilitate RMT ISK sales.

CCP’s justification, aside from the usual claim of gambling being fun and enjoyable, is that this will allow players to obtain otherwise very expensive items like rare officer modules without having to blow their budget.  Again, as always with gambling, the emphasis is put on the benefit of the lone winner and not the losses incurred by the losers.

Leaving aside the high ground CCP claimed when they banned gambling previously, I spent some time at EVE Vegas watching CCP Larrikin do his presentation which dwelt for quite a bit on income inequality in New Eden.  You can watch it here if you like.  As with the real world, no matter what happens, the rich seem to get richer.

And HyperNet Relay will be no different.  Despite claims about ISK velocity and redistribution of assets, this will simply make the rich even more wealthy.  Who has these rare and valuable items in their hangars?  Who has the ISK to buy PLEX in order to get their HyperNet Relay Gambling Kit from the New Eden store without spending any real world cash?  And who will collect the ISK from these raffles, where the combined value of all the tickets will more then compensate for the price of the HyperNet Relay and the value of the item being raffled off?

And, on the flip side, who has to use real world cash to buy PLEX to  get ISK?  And who cannot afford these expensive items?  And who will lose their ISK far more often than not?

Same shit, different day.

But it is already live on the test server, which means CCP is committed and the CSM has been briefed and approved of the plan.  The expected go live date is December 10, 2019.

CCP is still eliciting feedback in a comment thread on the forums.  The tide there is running very much against the idea.  But this is an obvious money maker, so I’ll be interested to see if the usual claim that “your voice matters” will ring hollow yet again.  On Reddit things are even more brutal.

And all of this is being dropped into an environment where legislators in various countries are eyeing gambling in video games ever more closely.  At least lock boxes have the fig leaf of everybody getting some prize out of them as cover.  I thought CCP was being smart back in 2016, covering themselves from possible legal trouble.  Now we have this.  We’ll see if EVE Online has a high enough profile to get called out for this.

No matter what, I suspect that this story will run for a while.

Other reactions:

 

6 thoughts on “Gambling Returns to New Eden

  1. bhagpuss

    This reminded me of raffles in Everquest, which used to be both common and controversial. I’d forgotten all about them but they were an everyday feature for many years. Those were completely unregulated. Someone would just /shout or /ooc a prize value in Platinum and people would hand over an entrance fee and use the /roll command to see who the lucky winner was.

    At least I think that’s how it worked. I never actually participated but it was impossible not to be aware it was happening. Every so often there were massive disputes over someone scamming and not paying out but there never seemed to be a shortage either of people offering or taking the offer up. What with the raffles and the endless begging and the wizards and druids touting for taxi business and the enchanters selling crack it was like Camden Market on a weekend sometimes. It certainly made the place feel alive. It was annoying at the time but it was very much part of the “virtual world” aspect we all bemoan having lost.

    At least CCP’s version will give out a guaranteed prize every time, which is something, I guess.

    Liked by 2 people

  2. Wilhelm Arcturus Post author

    @Bhagpuss – It is tough to police what players do in game, and all the more so with EVE where scams are legit. The local channel in Jita is pretty much non-stop scams of all flavors. And EVE has an active economy like no other MMO with different channels available for sales.

    But this is CCP, having decided that they could not have gambling in the game at a time when gambling was coming under scrutiny, coming back three years later, when the scrutiny has increased and deciding that an over in-game gambling mechanic that requires a real world money investment is A-OK. It boggles the mind.

    The conspiracies theories about this are rife. (Though people seem to agree that this isn’t Pearl Abyss, that this is that special flavor of Icelandic tone deaf obliviousness.) This will be some drama. CCP put up this announcement and has since remained mum as the players fight it out.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Dinsdale Pirannha

    Mind-boggling.

    The only thing I take away from this is what a great original concept Eve was. Eve has weathered CCP catering to RMT cartels and various sociopaths, CCP employing corrupt employees, an utterly clueless CEO, and who knows how many other crises and associated bad press.

    Yet it still exists. Imagine where the game would be if it had been controlled the last 10 years by moral, competent people. People like me would still be playing.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. mikeazariah

    The thought you had about rmt occurred to me as well.

    The pessimist in me worries about legalities and such.The optimist in me hopes it might bring new life to the game. In reality? No idea. I would love to have seen the meeting with the legal dept when this idea was floated because it screams edgy to me. Too many countries and too many laws.

    The irony of this sort of raffle sometimes being called a Shines raffle just adds to the humour, for me.

    m

    Like

  5. Wilhelm Arcturus Post author

    @mikeazariah – It is a mixed bag. The message, in the context of both CCP history and current stated concerns, is odd. The legality is probably okay today. I am not buying into the “space lawyers” argumatic about it being obviously problematic. But, as I said elsewhere, gambling aspects of video games are getting legislative attention and this feels like waving a red flag in that direction. And it doesn’t help that I personally see gambling as problematic in and of itself or that I am suffering from space fatigue at the moment. We’ll see.

    Like

Voice your opinion... but be nice about it...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s